The facts behind Elizabeth Warren, her claimed ties to Native Americans and the insult of Trump “Pocahontas” –

The facts behind Elizabeth Warren, her claimed ties to Native Americans and the insult of Trump “Pocahontas”


Elizabeth Warren could never live under the accusation of falsely affirming the roots of Native Americans. The controversy arose during the successful Senate of the Democrats in Mbadachusetts in 2012, and continues to persecute it.

In the midst of the 2016 presidential race, then-candidate Donald Trump labeled him with the nickname Pocahontas, and he has been trotted by almost every chance he has, even at a White House ceremony to recognize Native American soldiers who fought in some of the fiercest battles of World War II.

Warren's central offense dates back to the mid-1980s, when she first formally notified school administrators that her family tree includes Native Americans. Warren said he grew up with family stories about both grandparents by his mother with Cherokee or Delaware blood.

That genealogical claim has zero documentary evidence to support it, according to a PolitiFact review of news databases and bulletins until 1986.

Before this controversy arose in 2012, Warren spoke publicly of having Native American roots, although he called himself Cherokee in a local Oklahoma cookbook in 1984.

There is no dispute that Warren notified formally to the officials at the University of Pennsylvania and then Harvard claiming the inheritance of Native Americans after they hired her.

Its detractors say that it implemented a false connection between Native Americans to improve their chances of obtaining teaching jobs in two of the country's main law faculties. However, there is no evidence that Warren has gained a special advantage in his career.

The first mention

Warren's legacy was not something he mentioned during his 2012 senatorial election against Republican Scott Brown.

questions began with a story from Boston Herald on April 27, 2012.

"Elizabeth Warren's well-known Native American heritage, which the candidate rarely discusses in the election campaign, was once promoted by the beleaguered Harvard Law School officials who cited his claim as proof of the diversity of his faculty, "the article began. What the article revealed dates back more than a decade to the diversity records kept by Harvard.

At a time when the law schools faced public pressure to show greater ethnic diversity within their faculties, the newspaper Crimson of the university quoted El [Boston Globe] followed the Herald with a report that the Association of American Law Schools listed Warren as a minority law professor each year between 1986 and 1994. At that time, Warren went from being a law professor at the University of Texas to the University of Pennsylvania and finally in 1995 to Harvard University.

That badociation received lists of professors of law schools and sent personal profile forms to the new faculty members. The group asked for the first time about the state of the minority in 1986.

The directories do not indicate to which minority group the person belonged, so Warren was not obvious to schools or other readers that he was thinking about his native roots American [19659002] It is not certain that the directory form has given Warren the option to identify as a Native American. All we know with certainty is that the directory listed the faculty of law that self-identified as a minority.

Given the badociation's process of submitting the form to the new faculty, it is possible that Warren completed that form three times: once in 1986 when he was at the University of Texas, in 1987 when he moved to the University of Pennsylvania, and a third time when she spent a year as a visiting professor at Harvard in 1992. In 1995, when she moved to Harvard, she no longer appears. on the list of minority teachers.

Roots without a paper trail

Warren's campaign team could never discover any document that confirmed the Native American heritage in his family.

The New England Historical Genealogical Society also could not find any.

& # 39; We have no evidence that the great-great-great-great-great-grandmother of Elizabeth Warren OC Sarah Smith is or is not of Cherokee descent, & # 39; society spokesman Tom Champoux told the Herald a story from May 2012. (When we called the company, a spokesperson said we should see his 2012 statements)

Warren's final explanation was that he was turning to family stories.

"When I was a kid, I never asked my mom about the documentation when she talked about our Native American heritage," Warren said in an advertisement for the 2012 campaign. "What child would you do? My father's family did not like me to be part Cherokee and part Delaware, so my parents had to elope. "

Warren's extended family offered a mixed version of those stories to Boston Globe reporters.

Gloria Wysong, a cousin, said her mother told her that the family's legacy "was Delaware, but Delaware and Cherokee merged."

And David Herring, Warren's brother, said he grew up listening: "Your grandfather is part of Delaware, a little bit, way back, and your grandmother is part of Cherokee."

But other cousins ​​did not have those memories.

The main conclusion of the Globe reports was that many of those who had ties with Native Americans hid them, and the documentation of the end of the last century was irregular. In any case, the ties were so distant that they would not qualify it as a minority according to any official criteria.

Warren herself did not proclaim this side of her family's story. When applying to the university and the law school, the records show that she identified as white or did not apply according to the minority state.

Warren's First Responses

Warren Scott Brown's opponent jumped on the revelations and called upon her to apologize because Harvard has touted their dubious ethnic roots. Brown also said that he had used an invented minority state to make himself more attractive to the law faculties.

Warren refused to apologize, saying he did not know that Harvard was promoting it that way. She confirmed, however, that she had told the law school badociation that she had a minority status.

"I listed (in the) directory with the hope that I could be invited to a lunch, to a group something, with people who are like me," Warren told reporters on May 3, 2012. "It never happened That was not the use at all and I stopped controlling it. "

Warren rejected the idea that his ethnic status helped his appointments in law school.

& # 39; & # 39; I'm a working teacher, I've won teaching awards, I've written books that have been acclaimed, "Warren told reporters. "I applied for a job in 1978 by letter, and every job I've had since then has been from someone who recruited me in that job, and they came to me and told me, and now they've said it publicly: & # 39; For their job , we would like you to come here & # 39 ;. "

Any special treatment?

Several people involved in hiring her at Harvard and the University of Pennsylvania lent their support to that claim.

Harvard Law School professor Charles Fried, who served as United States Attorney General under President Ronald Reagan and was part of the committee that placed Warren in a tenure position, said in a written statement that his ethnicity never emerged during the process.

Fried, who donated $ 250 to the Warren campaign, said the Republican a Springfield, Mbadachusetts, newspaper in 2012, "This tells me that she was an affirmative action person, received some kind of impulse, he's so ridiculous and so desperately stupid and ignorant. "

When asked about Warren's minority status, Robert H. Mundheim, the dean who hired Warren at the University of Pennsylvania, told the Boston Globe that summer: "I do not like it". I think I never knew that she had those attribuses and that would not have changed much. "

Several news organizations interviewed dozens of professors and students from the three law schools where Warren taught, and no evidence emerged that any statement about his ethnic roots will play a role in the hiring process.

That has not shaken his critics, including a scathing opinion piece in the conservative National Review but even that article acknowledged that solid evidence was lacking of favoritism.

Warren Initially said that she did not remember having listed her origin in the United States when she performed the hiring process for either of the two jobs.Approximately one month after the controversy hit, she modified that to say that said after the fact.

"At some point after I was hired by them, I also provided it to information to the University of Pennsylvania and Harvard, "he said. He said in a statement issued by his campaign: "My Native American heritage is part of who I am, I'm proud of it, and I've been open about it."

Generally, Warren would have filled out forms to track the diversity of the faculty. The Boston Globe found that Harvard reported on a Native American teacher when Warren was there as visiting professor, and then again when he joined the permanent faculty. The University of Pennsylvania had similar reports.

Neither the schools nor Warren have opened the personnel files that could add more details.

A recipe for shame

The final fragment of Warren's tribe tale is trivial, but it has delighted its endless critics.

In 1984, a cousin in Oklahoma asked him to contribute recipes for a cookbook cataloged as "recipes transmitted through the families of the Five Tribes." The book was entitled Pow Wow Chow .

Warren sent five, and under each one, she listed herself as Elizabeth Warren, Cherokee.

Since a cousin asked him to participate, this could give credence to the notion that, at least in his family, a tribal connection was taken for granted.

But it did not help that his recipes included one for crab with mayonnaise and another for tomatoes with herbs: an untraditional meal.

To make matters worse, some of the recipes seem to have been copied from the New York Times cable service .

Share the facts

2017-12-01 16:23:05 UTC [19659056] PolitiFact “/>




  Logo of the PolitiFact rating ] PolitiFact Rating:

He told law schools

The facts behind Elizabeth Warren, her alleged ties to Native Americans and the insult of "Pocahontas" by Trump

It emerged during the race of the Mbadachusetts Senate 2012

Saturday, April 28, 2012


Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.