Repairing the college football tiebreaker, with or without the state of Ohio – Bill Livingston (photos)


CLEVELAND, Ohio – In the six seasons that Urban Meyer has trained at Ohio State, he has won only one Big Ten championship. On Saturday night in Indianapolis against Wisconsin, his Buckeyes seek his second.

A failure? Hardly.

Meyer's record is 71-8 with a national championship in 2014 and an undefeated season in 2012, when the Buckeyes were on probation due to infractions in the previous administration of Jim Tressel.

The Big Ten championship was not even worth a postseason job in college football last season. Ohio State, which lost the Eastern Division playoff due to a face-to-face loss to Penn State, received the approval of the CFP as a result of a horse exchange by the 13-member committee that selects and plants the field.

Commitment to the regular season

Conference champions should only have been an obvious criterion for CFP, with no exceptions, particularly with only four seats open for Power 5 conferences, the other five conferences of FBS and Notre Dame. [19659002] Skipping a conference champion compromises the only thing that makes college football different. That, of course, is the unequivocal and definitive rule that each game counts, that the regular season has real meaning, and that the Buckeyes can not save their "Big Three" from, say, J.T. Barrett, J.K. Dobbins and Nick Bosa on a trip, for example, to Iowa City, for everything that looked that way at a loss of 55-24.

Big Ten Shame

Ohio State got the offer last year in its regular season record of three wins over teams ranked in the Top 10 at that time.

One of them was Nebraska, which the Buckeyes exceeded, 62 -3, and which has been an impostor for years.

That charge could be made against the Big Ten as a whole. While the CFP was never lost, which began in 2014, the conference representatives after the amazing 2014 Buckeyes championship have been overcome and surpbaded. Michigan State was a 38-0 loser to Alabama in 2015, and Ohio State dropped by 31-0 to Clemson last season.

A modest proposal

Obviously, by Penn.Live a discussion can be made that the playoffs need to expand to eight teams, consisting of the five Power 5 conference champions and three jokers, at least one reserved for minor conferences.

This would at least reduce the evils of a system that has the appearance of equity, but which, in reality, is controlled by a committee of power brokers, accustomed to getting away with it, without accounting to anyone to such an extent that could well be called the Network of Old Boys.

The only exit

The sites have already been designated for future championship games until 2024.

Nothing will change quickly unless Wisconsin defeats Ohio State and is still snubbed by two teams from the Southwest Conference.

Commissioner Ten Jim Delany will later throw the biggest whistle since Jim Harbaugh of Michigan complained about the place at J.T. Barrett's fourth attempt burned everything.


The injury suffered by Ohio quarterback J.T. Barrett on the bench when a cameraman's team hit his knee at Michigan Stadium was not the first collision with Ohio State photographers and cameramen.

In 1973, before the Rose Bowl game, coach Woody Hayes pushed a camera in front of a Los Angeles Times photographer. He was fined $ 2,000 and suspended for three games.

In 1977, after a late fumble condemned the state of Ohio against Michigan, Hayes hit ABC Television cameraman Mike Friedman.

He was asked why television cameramen were authorized on the sideline, Michigan Coach Bo Schembechler also objected, Michigan athletic director Don Canham said: "Oh, $ 600,000 (in rights fees) Boys (writers) give us 600 thousand dollars, we will put their fancies on the bench "

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.