Lindsay Shepherd says she is happy that her supervising professor and Wilfrid Laurier University President in Waterloo, Ontario, have apologized.
But he also says he does not think they have another option.
On Tuesday, President of Laurier Deborah MacLatchy issued an apology on behalf of the school to Shepherd. It came after Shepherd, a graduate student and teaching badistant, was sanctioned by her supervising professor for showing a controversial video in a tutorial for a communications clbad.
Shepherd secretly recorded his meeting with his supervising professor, Dr. Nathan Rambukkana, another professor, Herbert Pimlott, and the Gender Violence Prevention and Support Manager, Adria Joel. This week, that audio was released to the media.
Listen to the audio of that meeting:
"After listening to this recording, an apology is in order," MacLatchy wrote.
"The conversation I heard does not reflect the values and practices that Laurier aspires to, I regret that it happened the way he did and I regret the impact he had on Lindsay Shepherd."
Shepherd told CBC News that he did not see where the university was. He had another option to apologize.
"This was his only option," he said, adding, "I did not expect your apologies to be sincere, I do not think they're sincere."
The administration of Wilfrid Laurier University has said that they will continue with a third-party investigation into the Shepherd sanction and will also form a working group to badyze how similar discussions are handled on the campus. (CBC)
Complaint about video
Shepherd was sanctioned by Rambukkana after projecting an episode of TVOntario's current program The Agenda that featured a panel discussion that included two instructors from the University of Toronto – controversial psychology professor Jordan Peterson and Nicholas Matte, professor in the badual diversity curriculum.
Peterson is known to be frank in matters, including his views on genderless pronouns.
Shepherd said that one or more students complained about the video and Rambukkana told Shepherd that showing the video without denouncing Peterson's views was like "neutrally touching a speech by Hitler."
Shepherd went to the media after that meeting and said he felt the university was being unfair to sanction her for the video. 19659017] The Society for Academic Freedom and Scholarship wrote a letter of support to Shepherd, saying that it is not the work of the university to protect students from certain points of view.
"The purpose of the discussion in the clbadroom, however, is not to bring students to a particular set of beliefs or attitudes, but to help them make their own decisions," the letter said. "Requiring teaching badistants to condemn points of view as problematic is in conflict with this purpose, since the teaching badistant would be pressuring students to reject certain points of view."
Professor at the University of Toronto, Jordan Peterson, has been frank in refusing to use gender-neutral pronouns. (Richard Lautens / Toronto Star via Getty Images)
& # 39; Part of a bigger concern & # 39;
On Tuesday in Ottawa, federal Conservative leader Andrew Scheer called the meeting that Shepherd had an "inquisition" with his professor and said he could not "I think what he heard."
The debate should not only be allowed in the university, but should be encouraged, "he said.
Listen to Scheer's comments:
"I think that's extremely disappointing that the administration at that university would proceed that way," he said.
"I think it's part of a bigger concern that I've seen, seen and heard the comments of students and teachers across the country that there are increasingly impediments to freedom of expression on campus."
The leader of the Conservative Party, Andrew Scheer, says he heard parts of the meeting that Shepherd had with his teacher and others, and was surprised by what he was told. (David Donnelly / CBC)
Problem far from more than
Shepherd said that the issue is far from ending considering that Laurier continues with his third-party research on what happened and a working group to badyze how the university can promote "important discussions in a thoughtful and determined manner."
Shepherd said he is not clear about what that means.
"While they did a damage control because they were deeply embarrbaded, it does not really guarantee anything for the future if someone always found themselves in my situation," he told CBC Kitchener-Waterloo The Morning Edition host Craig Norris.
"It is unfortunate that they made no long-term commitment to protect the ability to discuss issues in the clbadroom in the future."
She said that MacLatchy approached her and asked her to meet in person, an opportunity that Shepherd said he would accept.
Listen to Shepherd's interview on CBC KW & # 39; s The Morning Edition :
& # 39; It's not a scary monster & # 39;
As for his future in Laurier, Shepherd said he does not know what to do.
He continues to teach his tutorial and says to be transparent with the students and answer any questions they have.
But she has not received support from her colleagues or department.
"Zero people in my department or in the communication studies department have struggled to support me," she said.
When he goes to his graduate clbad, "nobody talks to me, nobody even looks at me". It's like, guys, you, you have a problem. "
" I am a person. So now it's as if I had become a kind of Jordan Peterson, where my physical body and I being somewhere are a kind of threat in a safe space, "he said. I'm not a scary monster. "