Welcome again, Oklahoma and Ohio State.
Keep in mind the Sooners and Buckeyes matchup from Week 2? They have been nationwide title contenders enjoying within the greatest recreation within the nation. First-year head coach Lincoln Riley picked up his first profession highway win. Certainly you keep in mind the flag that was planted? It looks like an eternity in the past that OU went into Columbus, Ohio, and beat the Buckeyes 31-16 in what was — and arguably nonetheless is — crucial nonconference win of the season.
Do not forget about that recreation, as a result of the 13 members of the Faculty Soccer Playoff choice committee will not, both. The query is how a lot they may nonetheless worth it after they meet Monday in Grapevine, Texas, and whether or not OU’s head-to-head win trumps the progress the Buckeyes seem to have made since their loss. With its 39-38 win over No. 2 Penn State on Saturday, Ohio State now boasts the most effective win within the nation.
However after 9 weeks, that is all it has — together with the loss to OU.
With Penn State and TCU shedding, two spots have been up for grabs on this week’s high 4. And with a convincing win over NC State — after final week’s overcome USC — Notre Dame works its approach into the playoff image.
Who says the SEC has misplaced its dominance? Not within the Energy Rankings. Georgia’s commanding win over Florida places the Bulldogs behind solely Alabama on this week’s rankings.
From euphoria at Ohio State, to madness at Iowa State, to Florida’s folly, Saturday’s video games could have long-lasting implications on the playoff race, the teaching scorching seat and extra. And all of it came about over about 200 action-packed minutes.
Had TCU and Penn State each received on Saturday and stayed undefeated, this might have been very neat and tidy for the committee. The Mbadive 12 and Mbadive Ten front-runners possible would have joined SEC heavyweights and unbeatens Alabama and Georgia within the preliminary high 4, which will likely be launched together with your complete high 25 on Tuesday (7 p.m. ET on ESPN and within the ESPN App). As an alternative, this seems to be a muddy mess of comparable one-loss groups, with Ohio State and Oklahoma probably inflicting an excellent debate throughout the Choice Central badembly room.
Alabama and Georgia look like no-brainers, with the one debate being which order they are going to be positioned in at No. 1 and No. 2.
However what about all these one-loss groups? Notre Dame is trying stronger by the week, having crushed NC State on Saturday, its second straight win over a top-15 opponent. The Irish’s solely loss got here by one level to Georgia, and they’re making a robust case to be the highest one-loss workforce. Ohio State has the most effective win. Clemson has the worst loss. Oklahoma’s loss would not look practically as dangerous now that Iowa State has cracked the Related Press High 25 and earned one other signature win towards TCU.
What makes the committee’s course of so vastly completely different from the AP ballot, although, is that its badysis goes past these single video games that spotlight every résumé for higher or for worse. As thrilling, dramatic and significant as Ohio State’s win was, it is solely a fraction of what the committee will consider when it considers the Buckeyes.
It additionally has the freedom — and the established precedent — to deem Ohio State higher than Oklahoma despite the head-to-head end result if it thinks these groups are not comparable. We have seen it earlier than with the Buckeyes, after they have been chosen for a CFP semifinal spot as an alternative of Penn State final 12 months regardless that they misplaced to the Nittany Lions.
Who’s to say the committee would not do it once more, this time at Oklahoma’s expense?
The Buckeyes’ J.T. Barrett was an ideal 13-for-13 within the fourth quarter for 170 yards and three touchdowns, together with the sport winner. He accomplished his closing 16 move makes an attempt of the sport, a far cry from his pedestrian efficiency within the Sept. 9 loss to OU. And Heisman Trophy contender Saquon Barkley rushed for a season-low 44 yards. Ohio State has had loads of time to enhance, and is the clear chief within the Mbadive Ten East.
You’ll hear CFP committee chair Kirby Hocutt and government director Invoice Hanbad say repeatedly over the subsequent month that choosing the highest 4 is a couple of workforce’s total physique of labor. Past the Buckeyes’ win over Penn State, they’ve finished nothing that may in any other case put them into the highest 4. They’ve crushed Military and UNLV. None of their previous three Mbadive Ten opponents — Rutgers, Maryland and Nebraska — is over .500. This was their first win over a ranked opponent this season.
However they did not lose to Syracuse, as Clemson did. Again to the whole-body-of-work factor.
Clemson’s win over two-loss Auburn definitely takes a backseat to Ohio State’s win over Penn State. However the Tigers have confronted a more difficult convention schedule than the Buckeyes. Even Boston Faculty, Wake Forest and an unraveling Louisville workforce have profitable information.
On Saturday towards Georgia Tech, Clemson regarded just like the workforce that started off 6-Zero, not the one which misplaced to Syracuse. The choice committee will issue within the damage to Clemson quarterback Kelly Bryant within the Tigers’ loss to Orange, however defensively, Clemson didn’t carry out effectively in that recreation.
We’ll get a way of the committee’s pondering when it releases its rankings on Tuesday. It is the primary of six rankings, however it’s going to reveal how extremely the committee regards the Mbadive Ten, and if it comes at a value to the Mbadive 12.