Mexico fights to cease Texas from executing convicted assassin, citing treaty


At right, Ruben Ramirez Cardenas, who is set to be executed. At left, Mexico's Deputy Foreign Minister for North America Carlos Manuel Sada Solana speaks at a news conference about the case.

At proper, Ruben Ramirez Cardenas, who is ready to be executed. At left, Mexico’s Deputy Foreign Minister for North America Carlos Manuel Sada Solana speaks at a information convention concerning the case.


After 20 years on dying row, a Mexican nationwide on the heart of a world dispute is scheduled to be put to dying by deadly injection Wednesday night time in Texas except an 11th hour attraction is profitable.

Ruben Ramirez Cardenas is ready to die Wednesday for the February 1997 beating dying of his 15-year-old cousin Mayra Laguna.

Cardenas informed police he and his buddy Jose Antonio Lopez Castillo have been on medication once they drove to Laguna’s residence and raped her. When he untied his cousin she “came at me,” he mentioned, scratching and kneeing him. He mentioned he “lost it” after which began punching her within the face.

When he hit her within the neck, Laguna began to cough up blood. Cardenas tried to revive her. When that didn’t work, he tied her again up and “rolled her down a cbad bank.”


It’s what occurred subsequent that has Mexican officers and human rights teams arguing he shouldn’t be put to dying.

Cardenas’ protection crew, funded by the Mexican authorities, claims the United States violated a world treaty by denying Cardenas the chance to talk to his nation’s consulate after his arrest.

‘This man deserves the dying penalty.’

– Rene Guerra, prosecutor

“It’s a significant treaty violation,” Gregory Kuykendall, an Arizona legal professional licensed to talk on behalf of Mexico, informed the Houston Chronicle.

If Texas officers execute Cardenas, they might be in obvious violation of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations.

In 2004, the U.N.’s worldwide court docket within the Hague dominated that the U.S. should badessment circumstances much like Cardenas’. Then-President George W. Bush informed states to conform however the Supreme Court overruled him and mentioned it was as much as Congress – not the president – to order states to obey.

Since then, Congress has dragged its ft. 

“The result: an illegal loophole states are exploiting to execute foreign nationals in violation of international law,” the ACLU says.

The U.N. excessive commissioner for human rights issued a press release Tuesday calling for the dying sentence “to be annulled and for Mr. Cardenas to be re-tried in compliance with international standards relating to due process and fair trial.”

Kuykendall provides that the legality of the treaty was by no means in query and due to this fact needs to be adopted.

“It’s not a question of whether there really is a binding legal obligation or not, every justice in the Supreme Court agrees that there is,” Kuykendall, who heads up the Mexican Capital Legal Assistance Program, mentioned. “The only question is who is going to implement the legal mechanism to put it into place.”

Mexico, not like the U.S., doesn’t have capital punishment. The nation hasn’t weighed in on whether or not Cardenas dedicated the crimes however as an alternative has centered on the treaty.

Cardenas additionally reportedly was denied a lawyer for 11 days. His attorneys argue that the DNA proof towards him is defective, his confession was coerced and their shopper is harmless.

But Rene Guerra, the previous native district legal professional who prosecuted Cardenas, dismissed the complaints. 

“I never would have authorized a case that was not there or was a flimsy investigation,” he informed The Associated Press. “This guy deserves the death penalty.”

If Cardenas is executed, he could be the 166th inmate to be executed in Texas up to now decade. He’d be the 11th Mexican nationwide to be executed within the U.S. in 35 years.

Source hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.