During the Republican main contest, Donald Trump feuded ceaselessly with Fox News, going after Megyn Kelly and, on the peak of his pique, even skipping one of many community’s debates. That now looks as if eons in the past. When staunch Trump supporter Laura Ingraham launched her new 10 p.m. present final week, it represented a capstone within the yearlong remaking of Fox News in Trump’s picture.
It additionally signaled that Fox fears growing competitors on its proper flank.
Story Continued Below
The community’s new prime-time lineup, that includes Ingraham, Sean Hannity and Tucker Carlson, who was added in April, varieties a three-hour nightly block of stable Trump cheerleading. Factor within the Trump-friendly morning present, “Fox & Friends,” on from 6 a.m. to 9 a.m., and in the course of the community’s most-watched hours, seldom is heard a discouraging Trump phrase.
“I’ve read the stories about how the Murdochs have soured on Donald Trump, but you would not know it from their programming decisions,” mentioned Charlie Sykes, the longtime conservative radio host and MSNBC contributor. “It certainly reflects the business model of conservative media right now. Pro-Trump viewers want a safe space. They want a reliable outlet that will defend the president and attack his critics and Fox has apparently decided that it’s going to give them that.”
As if to drive the purpose residence, Fox News made waves over the weekend by pulling from its air an advert calling for the president’s impeachment. Networks usually run advertisements of all political stripes, no matter ideology, however the 60-second impeachment spot, funded by liberal billionaire Tom Steyer, proved too offensive to too lots of the community’s viewers. “Due to the strong negative reaction to their ad by our viewers, we could not in good conscience take their money,” Jack Abernethy, co-president of Fox News, mentioned in an announcement.
On Tuesday night time and Wednesday, Fox hosts uniformly downplayed the concept Trump was an element within the Democratic victories in Virginia and New Jersey, taking pains to drive residence the president’s badertion that Virginia GOP gubernatorial nominee Ed Gillespie had erred in not embracing him intently sufficient.
Chris Ruddy, CEO of rival conservative platform Newsmax and a Trump ally, mentioned even he has been bowled over by Fox hosts’ unwillingness to criticize the president. If Fox has shifted to guard itself on the correct, Ruddy believes there’s now a gap for a conservative outlet that feels much less reflexively defensive of Trump.
“Newsmax is very supportive of the president, but we also will publish things that are critical of him time to time,” Ruddy mentioned. “Fox appears to have determined to develop into very intently aligned, which appears unnatural, and it doesn’t appear constant.
“It’s just bizarre and I think they lose their credibility as a news organization,” he continued.
Fox News declined further remark for this story.
Though Fox News stays tops within the scores, competitors is swirling across the community. The conservative Sinclair Broadcast Group is working to finish a $three.9 billion takeover of Tribune Broadcasting, which might permit its free broadcasts to achieve 72 p.c of U.S. households. Ruddy’s Newsmax TV at present has nowhere close to Fox’s attain, however it is usually trying to develop. POLITICO has reported that it just lately signed a cope with DISH Network to extend its distribution.
And Ruddy was scheduled to satisfy with Bill O’Reilly this week in New York to debate a possible spot on the community. Rumors have additionally linked O’Reilly and Sinclair, although its CEO and president, Chris Ripley, has denied any curiosity.
Beyond the TV world, there are a number of web sites — beginning with Breitbart — that threaten Fox News’ primacy over discourse on the correct.
“There’s a lot of conservative media out there,” mentioned Joseph Bonner, a senior badyst for communications and expertise at Argus Research. “If Fox thinks the threat is from the right or the Trumpists, however you want to put it, to inoculate against that threat, you want to have that point of view.”
Less than a yr in the past, the Fox News prime-time lineup featured O’Reilly and Kelly, along with the ardently pro-Trump Sean Hannity. While neither O’Reilly nor Kelly’s reveals have been precisely bastions of liberal politics, Kelly famously took on Trump. And although a Trump supporter, O’Reilly, who was pressured out of Fox News in April within the wake of a number of badual harbadment allegations, often confirmed willingness to buck the Trump line. Their replacements, Ingraham and Tucker Carlson, nearly by no means break from the president.
The week earlier than beginning her present, Ingraham appeared with Steve Bannon at a political rally for Kelli Ward, the hard-right Arizona Senate candidate who had been difficult Trump critic Jeff Flake — a seemingly bare declaration that Ingraham is extra a political operative than a journalist.
“It’s quite a significant pivot. For people who believe Fox has always been pro-Trump, they miss the significance of how hard the shift has been in the last 18 months,” Sykes mentioned. “Fox is really turning itself very self-consciously into virtually a house organ of the Trump administration.”
Particularly noteworthy, he mentioned, was the community’s current embrace of Hillary Clinton-related tales that appear designed to deflect consideration from particular counsel Robert Mueller’s Russia investigation.
“There’s nothing about conservative ideas. This is not about the size of government, this is not about tax cuts. This is about defending the regime against legal attack,” Sykes mentioned.
Some Fox News anchors, like Shepard Smith, Bret Baier and Chris Wallace, have remained prepared to sound discordant notes, and Fox has added further information programming because the election, together with a just-launched newscast at 11 p.m. But the Clinton-focused tales have discovered important airtime throughout Fox’s information programming, as properly — way over on every other community.
In the previous, Fox News, underneath Roger Ailes, had sought to guide its viewers ideologically. The community, as an illustration, was on the ahead fringe of selling the tea get together motion throughout Barack Obama’s first time period as president. Now, although, Ailes is gone and Fox seems extra centered on badembly its viewers the place they’re.
That is, partially, as a result of the community faces a far completely different media ecosystem in the present day. In the outdated days, Fox was free to set the agenda. But the explosion in recognition of each social media and conservative websites like Breitbart, Infowars and The Gateway Pundit have now pressured the community to ensure it doesn’t get left behind by no matter is effervescent up on-line.
“I think that Fox is making the same decision that Trump himself is making, which is double down in your appeal to your hard-core base,” Sykes mentioned. “They didn’t hire Laura Ingraham because they want to get viewers from MSNBC.”
The entry supplied by cozying as much as Trump — Fox’s No. 1 viewer — has been a boon to the community, mentioned Brian Wieser, a senior badyst at Pivotal Research. Since he took workplace, Trump has granted 19 interviews to Fox News or Fox Business Channel, in contrast with simply two for NBC and MSNBC, one for ABC News, one for CBS News and 0 for CNN.
“They’ve certainly found that they can have Trump’s ear,” he mentioned. “They know there’s advantage to access. I suspect that’s the more important element than is sheer ideology.”
After Ingraham, whose title had beforehand surfaced as a possible Trump press secretary, interviewed the president on Thursday, The Washington Post described the interview as, “as obliging as would be expected of someone who previously contemplated a role as the president’s official mouthpiece.”
Trump’s look on Ingraham’s present prompted a big spike in her scores, with greater than three million folks tuning in, in keeping with Nielsen, in contrast with 2.36 million the night time earlier than.
Whether a conservative challenger might probably dent Fox News stays an open query. Wieser mentioned that doing so can be extremely troublesome, requiring “hundreds of millions of dollars in upfront capital commitments.”
“I look at the ratings on a regular basis and clearly Fox is doing outrageously well,” mentioned Charles Herring, president of the Fox rival One America Network’s father or mother firm, Herring Networks. “I do believe that anybody who’s trying to compete with them has an uphill battle, but we’ve been able to carve out a really nice audience of independents and right-wing individuals, and we believe there’s a lot of upside potential for growth.”
Herring believes that Fox News viewers might react negatively to the community’s daytime information packages not having the identical hard-core pro-Trump viewpoint because the prime-time opinion lineup. “If you’re a viewer, you’re getting two different messages, depending if you’re watching during the day or the evening prime-time lineup. And I think that’s a really tough act for a channel to do, to try to appeal to two audiences,” he mentioned.
Though it’s unlikely a conservative challenger might instantly come alongside and knock Fox News off its pedestal, if one other outlet grabbed even sufficient viewers to permit surging MSNBC to sneak forward of Fox within the scores, it might be a blow to the community, which has lengthy made its No. 1 standing central to its branding.
“It’s cable television. Bragging rights are relevant,” Bonner, the badyst, mentioned.
Ruddy mentioned that Fox’s success is proof that there’s loads of room within the conservative market, particularly for a community extra prepared to supply “constructive criticism” of Trump.
“My view is we’re not challenging Fox, we’re just adding to the diversity of the marketplace,” Ruddy mentioned. “Tucker, Laura and Hannity, that’s going to be a very predictable lineup largely. My view would be more independent voices. I think in the long run this is better for conservatives, it’s better for President Trump.”