In an interview on CNBC’s “Squeak Box”, Emanuel stated that tens of thousands of American lives could have been spared by a more harmonious national strategy.
Emanuel’s comments were based on his research published on Monday on the JAMA Network website of the Journal of the American Medical Association. They analyzed per capita mortality from coronoviruses including the US and 18 other countries, including Australia, Germany and the UK. The paper found that since May 10, Kovid-19 in the US has caused more deaths per 100,000 people than in any comparable countries. .
According to Emanuel’s research, the US has more coronaviruses per capita than the other 18 countries since June 7. However, since the onset of the epidemic, there have been more deaths per 100,000 people in Belgium, at 86.8, Spain at 65.0, and at 62.6 in the UK, at 60.3 in the US.
Emanuel, a professor of medical ethics and health policy at the University of Pennsylvania’s medical school, emphasized the findings that since May 10, US mortality has outstripped other countries. Since then, the country has “done exceptionally bad” compared to places like Italy.
Imamuel said that time frame was known, as most countries were in trouble before and “set their arms on how to manage the virus.” He added that this also adjusted for the fact that European nations might see considerable transmission of the virus in the US a week or two earlier.
Both Italy and the US have the same per capita mortality rate since the onset of the epidemic, which the papers consider February. 13. Italy has a rate of 59.1. But since May 10, Italy has experienced 9.1 deaths per Kovid-19 per 100,000 people, while Italy’s per capita death rate fell to 3.1 from June 7, compared with a rate of 36.9 in the US, while the US ‘27.2 Was. The data used in Emanuel’s paper goes through 19 September.
Emanuel, who was a health policy adviser to the Obama administration from 2009 to 2011, said, “We have had almost 90,000 more deaths since May 10, to date, while we should have followed the course of Italy – 90,000 Americans, which is unnecessary.” Died of. ”
“Italy has nothing more special or different in terms of treatment, vaccines, diagnostics than the United States,” he said. “They have better implementation of public health measures, and this could actually save thousands of lives in the United States.”
In particular, Emanuel stressed the lack of a coordinated national strategy in the US, stating that public health measures “require nationwide, with loyalty, and then slowly reopening.” He also said that the US struggled to build a strong network to perform contact tracing after a known infection, which could then be targeted to areas where the virus is spreading more quickly.
“We know that this virus breaks down into superseding events. It’s not normal person-to-person,” he said, citing research earlier this year that suggested 80% of new infections were infected. Can come from 10%. People.
Emanuel said, “So you have to be able to identify them and suppress them quickly. We’ve never built that capability.” “Under the federal government, [President Donald Trump], Transported it to the states, and then the states did very different things. ”
White House Deputy Press Secretary Sarah Matthews defended the Trump administration’s handling of the epidemic in a statement to CNBC, stating that “like all national emergencies, the response is most successful when it is locally executed, state-managed, and federally is supported.”
“President Trump’s unprecedented and coronovirus response across America has saved countless lives and the power and strength of the largest crowd since World War II – resulting in more than 100,000 ventilators purchased, a significant PPE for our frontline heroes Key Sourcing, a robust testing regime, conducted more than double the trials of any country in the world, and the fastest vaccine to test, which it wrote.
Emanuel’s comment is about some of the public health experts in America growing coronavirus infections during the fall and cold winter months. In CNBC’s “The News with Shepard Smith” Monday evening, the country’s top infectious disease specialist, Dr. Anthony Fauci said that the country “faces a lot of trouble ahead”.
Other countries in Europe are also rising in cases of Kovid-19, which have imposed tougher restrictions to prevent proliferation. British Prime Minister Boris Johnson on Monday unveiled a tire lockdown system for the UK. Last week, Paris temporarily closed its bar and gym as infection rates soared.
According to research by France, Emanuel, there have been 46.6 deaths per 100,000 people since the onset of the epidemic. From May 10, this figure drops to 7.5. It estimates 3.2 deaths since June 7.
Emanuel stressed that no country has fully responded to the epidemic, except “probably Taiwan”. According to data compiled by Johns Hopkins University, 529 coronovirus cases and seven deaths have been confirmed in a country of about 24 million people.
According to Johns Hopkins data, 7.8 million confirmed deaths of Kovid-19 and 215,089 deaths in the US.
“There’s a lot we could have done,” Emanuel said of the US response. “The problems we have here – the number of cases, the number of deaths, the number of hospitalizations – were not inevitable. It was a result of poor public health measures being implemented, or not being implemented, as the case may be. “