Evelyn Arroyo-Maultsby, the juror dismissed from the Menendez trial due to trip, speaks to the media outdoors of the federal courthouse on Thursday, November 9, 2017 in Newark, NJ.
Danielle Parhizkaran/

Evelyn Arroyo-Maultsby, the juror dismissed from the federal corruption trial for Sen. Bob Menendez, speaks to outdoors of the federal courthouse on Thursday, November 9, 2017 in Newark, NJ.(Photo: Danielle Parhizkaran/

NEWARK, N.J. — A lady excused from the jury Thursday at the corruption trial of U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez stated she was useless set towards convicting the New Jersey Democrat and his co-defendant.

“If I would have been there all the way to the end, it would have been not guilty,” said Evelyn Arroyo-Maultsby, 61, of Hillside. “All the way to the end, not guilty.”

But in what seems to be a stroke of unhealthy luck for Menendez and his co-defendant Salomon Melgen, the U.S. district court docket choose overseeing the case dismissed Arroyo-Maultsby on Thursday so she may take a long-scheduled trip. 

The 12-person jury within the case has not reached a unanimous verdict after three full days of deliberations and can resume its discussions Monday with an alternate juror in Arroyo-Maultsby’s place.

More: Cup of Politics: What’s at stake as Bob Menendez corruption trial nears an finish

More: Menendez verdict could rely upon how choose instructs jury on the definition of bribery

Arroyo-Maultsby described the dynamics within the jury room as “very stressful” and stated the “majority is still saying not guilty.”

But there may be not less than one adamant holdout, she stated, and estimated that three or 4 jurors whole have been leaning towards a conviction.

“We have someone in there that definitely doesn’t want to hear it,” she advised reporters as she left the federal courthouse in Newark. “I think it’s going to be a hung jury.”

She additionally stated she felt the federal government was “railroading” Menendez.

“I didn’t like this experience,” she stated. “The unfairness and how it’s being presented, talking about him being corrupt. I think the government is corrupt. I think the government was the crooked one, not Menendez.”

The U.S. Department of Justice didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark.

Miles Feinstein, a famous protection lawyer who dealt with many authorities corruption instances, stated the departing juror’s statements creates fertile floor for a mistrial.

He stated the truth that the departing juror is so adamant in her refusal to convict is an actual blow to the protection. But now that she’s gone, and the deliberation has to begin over, there’s actual strain on different hold-out jurors to collapse simply to complete the method.

“The fact that they have to start over, that’s really putting pressure on the jury,” Feinstein stated.


U.S. Senator Bob Menendez (D-NJ) arrives on the Martin Luther King Jr. Federal Courthouse on Thursday, November 9, 2017. Menendez is on trial for corruption fees.
Danielle Parhizkaran/

Arroyo-Maultsby’s reasoning for doubting the federal government’s case and holding that the boys have been “not guilty on all counts” echoed lots of the arguments made by protection attorneys in the course of the nine-week trial.

“That’s his friend,” she stated of Melgen, a rich Florida eye physician who has been shut with the senator for the reason that 1990s. “And if his friend wanted to take him anywhere he wants, why not? Just because he’s a senator, his friend can’t take him anywhere?”

She added: “When they stated that it was going to be conspiracy, that they deliberate this, that’s to me, I don’t see that. Planning that, no, I don’t see that. That’s a friendship.”

Menendez stands accused of utilizing his workplace to badist co-defendant Melgen safe visas for his international girlfriends and to intervene in a profitable port safety contract within the Dominican Republic and a multimillion-dollar Medicare dispute.

In change, prosecutors argued in court docket, Menendez took bribes within the type of luxurious holidays, free flights on Melgen’s non-public jets and $660,000 in political contributions.

Menendez has vigorously denied the costs, saying that he will probably be vindicated at trial and run for re-election subsequent 12 months.

In whole, Menendez faces six counts of bribery, three counts of sincere companies fraud, one rely of conspiracy, one rely of interstate journey to hold out bribery and one rely of constructing false statements on his congressional monetary disclosures to hide the crimes.

Melgen faces the identical fees apart from the false statements accusation.

The fraud fees carry probably the most severe penalty of as much as 20 years in jail.

Sen. Robert Menendez leaves the Martin Luther King Jr. Building and U.S. Courthouse in Newark on Wednesday, November eight, 2017.  (Photo: Michael Karas/

At one level Thursday, Arroyo-Maultsby stated there was dialogue amongst jurors about probably speaking to the choose overseeing the case, William H. Walls, to see if he may badist break their deadlock.

“I advised them that they are holding again on what I need to say and that we should always go and let the choose know the way we really feel, they usually did not need to,” she said. “They stated, properly, let’s go extra, perhaps he may change our thoughts. But then, I advised them they weren’t going to vary mine and there was no cause for them to attempt to change my thoughts.”

She additionally instructed that the opposite jurors might need been stalling throughout deliberations in hopes of getting an alternate much less dug-in on her view of the case.

“Really, personally, I feel they was holding and taking their time so the following particular person may come on,” Arroyo-Maultsby stated.

Feinstein stated the method has been tainted by letting the lady start the deliberations together with her trip looming, figuring out that she won’t end them.

And jurors aren’t allowed to debate the case with anybody outdoors the courtroom till after a verdict has been reached. The proven fact that the juror was excused after which selected to talk to the press has violated the secrecy of the deliberation course of, he stated.

“This opens an actual can of worms,” Feinstein stated. “The trial should not be in this position at this time.”

Feinstein wasn’t certain whether or not the choose was required by regulation to advise the departing juror towards speaking to the press, however he stated it will have been “common sense and logic” that he would accomplish that.

The state of affairs may have been prevented if the juror had not been allowed to start deliberations within the first place, provided that she won’t have the ability to end them.

“I would argue that a vacation is trumped by your duty as a juror,” Feinstein stated. “A vacation, as opposed to what’s at stake here? Go on vacation some other time.” 

Arroyo-Maultsby stated she wrapped up her civic obligation with some parting phrases for her fellow jurors.

“I said to them, ‘Please, make the right decision,’ because they’re the one that’s not going to be able to sleep at night,” she stated.

On his means out of the courthouse Thursday, Menendez stated — with out figuring out the views of the dismissed juror — he had “faith” that the alternative juror would be a part of the others in reaching a not-guilty verdict.

“I want to thank the juror who was excused for her service,” he stated.

Deliberations won’t be held Friday, Veterans Day, and are scheduled to renew Monday at 9:30 a.m. ET.

Follow Nicholas Pugliese and Catherine Carrera on Twitter: @nickpugz and @cattcarrera