Apple continues to be aggressive in its continuing legal battle with Epic Games with iOS version Fortnite. In a comprehensive motion filed on Tuesday afternoon, Apple defended itself against Epic’s legal allegations, while also alleging Fortnite Creator of breach of contract and outright theft.
“Although Epic portrays itself as a modern corporate Robin Hood, in reality it is a multi-billion dollar enterprise that simply does not want to pay anything for the tremendous value it receives from the App Store,” Apple writes Huh.
Who pays for what?
In its own legal filing, Epic Part seeks the right to provide “competitive payment processing on iOS” by going around the in-app shopping system built into the iOS App Store. Epic tried to do this unilaterally last month by adding a discounted Epic Direct Payments option to the iOS version. Fortnite, A move that led Apple to bar Epic from the App Store.
In addition to the breach of contract, Apple states in its proposal that there was a “Trojan horse” other than Epic’s direct payment which is “little more than theft.” Using a “hotfix” update method that was deliberately hidden from the App Store review process in general, Apple says that Epic “wants to enjoy all the benefits of Apple’s iOS platform and related services.” [lining] Epic’s pocket at Apple’s expense. ”
Later in the motion, Apple says that Epic’s introduction of direct payments into the game is “theft, period.”
Epic has happily agreed to the terms of Apple’s contract for the development of iOS since 2008, Apple writes, earning more than $ 600 million from App Store sales in that period. The fact that Epic no longer accepts that deal “does not provide cover for contracts that dissolve Epic, a longtime business partner, the Pocket Commission that is related to Apple, and then a judicial hearing from this court Ask to take one of the condemners. The most innovative business platform of the 21st century simply because it does not maximize Epic’s revenue, “Apple writes.
Apple said that the 30 percent iOS sales commission has attempted to get Epic a lot more than a simple fee to pay. Rather, this fee “reflects the enormous value of the App Store, which exceeds the sum of its parts and includes Apple’s technology, tools, software for app development and testing, marketing efforts, platinum-level customer service, and developers’ Includes distribution. “Apps and digital content.” It includes over 150,000 APIs that Apple has built to make iOS development easier, the company writes, as well as the Metal Graphics APIs that Epic has praised in the past is.
Apple wrote in a letter in July to Epic in response to Epic’s request, “The App Store is not a public utility. Epic has no rights” Apple and the App Store provide without paying a penny. The company said.
No you can’t have your own app store
In its recent filing, Epic states that “it does not force Apple to provide free delivery and processing services, nor does Epic want to enjoy Apple’s services without paying for them.”
Instead, Epic states that it is “free to not use Apple’s App Store or IAP, and instead to use and offer competing services on Apple’s hardware”, as it may be on Windows PCs. However, this is not possible, as Epic states that Apple has monopoly control over the market for all iOS software.
Apple directly states in its proposal that it “does not monopolize any relevant market” and that “competition is fierce at every level, both inside and outside the App Store: for devices, platforms, and personal apps.” More than that, though, Apple says that all iOS purchases go through the app store infrastructure, “essential to ensure that the iOS app meets Apple’s high standards for privacy, security, content and quality is.”
Apple cites Epic’s own example on other platforms as evidence of this requirement. When Epic started distributing Android version Fortnite Independently in 2018, Apple writes that “immediately appeared sites that not only advertise Android Fortnite But the game also distributed malware. “Apple also cites security vulnerabilities with independently distributed Android versions as evidence that its iOS security is necessary.
“Although Apple does not leave it to any developer to keep the iOS platform safe and secure, Epic in particular had demonstrated that it cannot be assigned this type of responsibility,” Apple writes.
In addition to compensatory and punitive damages related to breach of contract and other related violations, Apple is seeking an injunction to prevent Epic from continuing to use its own external payment processing mechanism in Accent copies of the iOS version. Fortnite Or future apps.